Persistence through the FOI swamp

Despite constant barriers, our chief Freedom of Information requester has been plugging away at the more reticent trusts. Here’s the latest update on our Trust referrals data campaign.

It is interesting how far some trusts go to avoid answering simple questions about the number of nurses and midwives that it has referred to the NMC.
I have been wrangling with Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust for over a year. I have complained to the ICO, but the Trust pleaded that as they had 9,500 staff registered with the NMC they couldn’t possibly give an answer. (Even though one senior person should have oversight and responsibility for signing off referrals and communicating with the NMC).


When I changed tack and asked the number of referrals from each individual hospital unit, they simply aggregated my requests and refused to answer!
Today, they bizarrely sent me a response that indicated they had chosen thirty-six individual staff records and found that of this random sample there had been two referrals to the NMC in the period 2019-2023.
Now that sample is 0.38% of their NMC registered staff, so if it is in any way representative of the referrals across the entire registrant working group of 9,500 nursing and midwifery staff, we are talking about over five hundred referrals which would be a national scandal.


Watch this space.
It’s a poor trust that has no idea how many hard-working nurses and midwives it has put through such a ghastly life event as a Fitness to Practice referral, but playing the sampling game has consequences for a trust’s reputation.

0 Comments

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Related posts:
Help Roger Kline investigate – deadline 31 Jan

Roger Kline is launching research into workplace investigations. As part of this, he is inviting people to take a survey. Email research@kline.org.uk for more information. DEAR COLLEAGUE JANUARY 8TH 2025 INVESTIGATING THE INVESTIGATORS Workplace investigations in...

The Fitness to Practice process: a practitioner’s perspective

Having spent years supporting registrants through the Nursing and Midwifery Council’s (NMC) Fitness to Practice process, I’ve seen its impact up close - and I’m here to tell you, the system is broken. written by Simon Holborn - Head of Advocacy at NMCWatch. I see the...

Too much wriggle room in FOI Act?

We have been building a data map looking at referral patterns from UK employers to the Nursing and Midwifery Council. We asked each organisation for the total number of nurses and midwives they referred between 2019 and 2023. Some trusts have readily provided this...

Gloucestershire trust breaches FOIA – ICO

On 29 November we published Gloucestershire Hospital NHS Foundation Trust's response to our Freedom of Information (FOI) request. They avoided the question, so we referred them to the Information Commissioner's Office (ICO). This is the ICO's resulting decision....

Manchester Uni Trust’s lack of transparency

You could assume some NHS trusts are living in la-la land, but Manchester University NHS Foundation Trust’s attitude to our Freedom of Information requests raises some serious concerns over their safeguarding of employees. Written by Penny Ballinger. Remember the old...